Today's photo
RFE/RL: Boris Nemtsov's Daughter Receives $1.1 Million Rights Prize From Poland
Amb. Chaly says top priority is building a new level of trust with the United States
Metinvest struggles to keep all of its steel holdings on target
Electronic Warfare: What US Army Can Learn From Ukraine
Kyiv Analyst Says Moscow Mulling ‘Nuclear Provocation’ Against Ukraine
Ukraine reports record high current account surplus in June
Ukrainian equities mostly down in Monday trading
WHO: - Better health begins with breastfeeding for baby’s early years
Putin’s “Turkish Stream” fiasco
IMF board approves USD 1.7 bln loan to Ukraine


Remember me

Advanced Search
Contact Us
Kyiv Ukraine

January 1, 1970

“Ukraine is Not Russia and Russia is Not the USSR,” Lukyanov Says

2014/2/5 19:04:23

“The Soviet system was ‘based on a symbiosis of the Horde traditions with totalitarian communist ideology,’ and ‘it is not surprising that out of this symbiosis arose one of the bloodiest and most despotic regimes known to human history,’ Lukyanov says.”


By Paul Goble*


February 5 – Ukraine has more in common with the other non-Russian countries who achieved or recovered their independence with the breakup of the Soviet Union than it does with the Russian Federation, and that gives Russia a chance to “throw up its horde-soviet shackles,” according to Aleksandr Lukyanov.


In a commentary on the liberal opposition portal yesterday, the Moscow analyst argues that “the victory of the Ukrainians will bring Russia closer to the day when it can throw off” the shackles it continues to wear and become a genuinely post-Soviet state as well (


Ukraine and Russia have developed along different lines for a millennium, Lukyanov points out.  Ukraine by accepting Christianity joined itself to Western civilization while the Vladimir-Suzdal state out of which Moscow emerged began as a vassal of the Golden Horde and was therefore “cut off from Europe.” It followed the Horde’s model of power: Asiatic despotism.


Although Kyiv was force initially to acknowledge the sovereignty of the Horde as well, he continues, many of its lands passed into the Grand Principality of Lithuania and “as a result of this, the ancestors of contemporary Ukrainians although they were deprived of their own statehood remained part of the European cultural-civilizational space.”


Since that time, there has been a struggle within Russia between “two traditions,” one flowing from the Horde and the other from Europe.  The former was never completely defeated even when the Horde suffered defeats, and the latter despite many attempts up through the 19th century, never completely succeeded although there appeared to be hope in the early 20th.


But that hope was extinguished by World War I and the ensuing Bolshevik revolution.  That event “was not only a change of power ... but le to the destruction of a genuinely Russian statehood with its conflict between the European and Horde traditions and broke off the process of the step by step return of Russia to its lawful place in the European family of peoples.”


The Soviet system was “based on a symbiosis of the Horde traditions with totalitarian communist ideology,” and “it is not surprising that out of this symbiosis arose one of the bloodiest and most despotic regimes known to human history,” Lukyanov says.


When the Soviet system weakened and collapsed, he continues, “in the republics, the anti-Soviet movement developed not only under the flag of anti-communism but also under that of the national-liberation struggle.” The Baltic countries were the most thorough-going in this regard, but the other non-Russian states were similar in this regard.


But the situation in Russia was different: “the majority of citizens of Russia considered (and up to now consider) Soviet statehood not as something alien but as their own, as one of the historical forms of genuinely Russian statehood.”  That is a misconception because both the components of the Soviet system – the Horde and Communism – were imported and imposed on the Russians as well.


“Soviet statehood was never a continuation of Russian statehood,” Lukyanov says, noting that the Bolsheviks “never considered Soviet Russia the historical and political successor of pre-revolutionary Russia.” They saw it only as a place des armes “for the creation of a future worldwide communist state.”


In this regard, he argues, “Soviet power was just as much an occupation regime in Russia as it was in Latvia, Lithuania, Ukraine or Georgia.” But the leadership of the Russian Federation did not understand that and declared their country to be “the legal successor of the Soviet Union,” a declaration that has fed “nostalgia for the USSR” over the last two decades.


Vladimir Putin, who has declared that the collapse of the USSR was “the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th century,” is in fact “a direct continuation of the Soviet regime.  More than that, all of Putin’s foreign policy justifies suggesting that he is seeking to create a ‘neo-USSR’ under the guise of a Eurasian Union.”


But that project will fail if it does not include Ukraine, Lukyanov argues. And Putin has failed to recognize that “the Ukrainian people does not want a return to the Soviet past but wants to build its own national state in the European civilizational space.”


“What is taking place today in Ukraine,” Lukyanov says, “is more than simply mass protests against an unpopular and corrupt regime. It is even more than a revolution.  This is a national-liberation Ukrainian-Soviet struggle.” If the Maidan loses, it will be a defeat not just for the Ukrainian opposition but for the Ukrainian nation.


But if the Maidan and the Ukrainian people win, that will represent a defeat of “the Soviet mythology on which the Putin regime operates and on Putin’s neo-Soviet project as a whole.”  Consequently, those who want to see the European element defeat the Horde one in Russia have an interest in a Maidan victory because that will be a victory for Russian democracy as well.




*Paul A. Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. Contact Goble at:


The op-ed above represents the views of the author. Ukraine Business Online presents this information merely as a matter of public information. Our publication of this material should not be construed in any way as an endorsement - or rejection - of the views contained therein.


Editor’s Note: Ukraine Business Online invites comments from readers on this or any other subject of interest to the Ukrainian people. You may provide feedback to any news story by use of the reply function at the bottom of the page. If you have more general thoughts you would like to share, send commentary of any length to:


Printer Friendly Page Send this Story to a Friend Create a PDF from the article
Poster Thread
Guest Posted: 2014/4/29 12:20
 Re: “Ukraine is Not Russia and Russia is Not the USSR,?... coach outlet coach outlet store online michael kors outlet michael kors outlet coach factory outlet coach factory outlet true religion outlet true religion jeans coach outlet online louis vuitto purses coach outlet store online michael kors purses louis vuitton handbags coach outlet true religion jeans coach factory outlet online coach factory outlet coach factory outlet louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet coach factory outlet online michael kors outlet michael korsoutlet store coach factory online tiffanys jewelry celine outlet cheap jerseys toms shoes alexander wang shoes alexander wang bags sac burberry celine bags toms outlet fitflops fitflop outlet giuseppe zanotti sneakers marc by marc jacobs prada outlet tiffany jewelry prada outlet michael kors marc jacobs giuseppe zanotti supra shoes Polo ralph lauren
Guest Posted: 2014/7/24 7:08
 Re: “Ukraine is Not Russia and Russia is Not the USSR,?... Super Bags Market Nike Jordan Shoes Beats By Dre Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online North Clearace Outlet Ralph Polo Outlet Gucci Shoes Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Polo Outlet Store Ralph Lauren UK Marc Jacobs On Sale MCM Outlet Hermes Outlet Online Sac Longchamp Pairs Canada Goose Outlet Burberry Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Oakley Sunglaases Factory North Face Outlet Online Moncler Clearance Woolrich Clearance Barbour Jackets Outlet Online Moncler Jackets Outlet Online Air Max Shoes Monster Beats Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Factory MCM ?? Discount Clothes Sale Michael Kors Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet Coach Black Friday Coach Store Outlet Online Coach Factory Outlet Online Coach Outlet Coach Factory Coach Purses Outlet Online Coach Outlet USA Michael Kors Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Online USA Coach Factory Outlet Online Black Friday Coach Purses Outlet Online Michael Kors USA Michael Kors Outlet USA Ralph Lauren Polo